Heading into retirement without a mortgage is a goal for many people. Clearing that monthly payment frees up income for the retirement you actually want, and it lifts a real weight off your shoulders. But should you pay off your mortgage before retiring by overpaying now, or is your money better invested elsewhere? As the following case study shows, the answer depends on your circumstances, and with a clear plan being mortgage free is often more achievable than people expect.
Note: the names below have been changed, and the figures are illustrative and were correct at the time of the original example. They are used to show our approach, not as a recommendation for your own situation.
The starting point
Keith, 55, and his wife Sharon, 53, hoped to retire in around ten years and to be mortgage free by the time they did. They had an outstanding mortgage balance of £140,000 over a 15-year term, on a fixed-rate deal, with monthly repayments they could comfortably afford alongside surplus income. As balanced investors, they wanted to know the smartest way to reach both goals: retiring on time and clearing the mortgage.
Should you overpay the mortgage, or invest?
This is the central question, and it comes down to a simple comparison: the interest rate on your mortgage versus the return you might reasonably expect from investing instead. If your mortgage rate is low and your investments are expected to grow faster, keeping the mortgage and investing the difference can leave you better off. If your mortgage rate is high, overpaying or clearing the balance may be the stronger, lower-risk choice.
At the time of Keith and Sharon’s plan, their mortgage rate was low relative to expected investment returns, which shaped the advice below. Today’s higher mortgage rates can tip that balance the other way, which is exactly why this decision needs to be looked at against your own numbers rather than a rule of thumb. Investment returns are never guaranteed, and the value of investments can fall as well as rise.
The advice we provided
Given their circumstances at the time, we set out a plan built around a few strands:
- Keep up regular mortgage repayments, which were comfortably affordable, rather than straining their budget to overpay.
- Build savings in a Stocks and Shares ISA over the decade ahead, aiming to grow their money tax-free and, given their low mortgage rate at the time, potentially faster than the cost of the mortgage.
- Model the options with cashflow planning: we compared using ISA lump sums to clear the mortgage against taking a higher pension and savings income for the first few years of retirement. Both routes showed them on track for their goals.
Because life rarely runs to plan, we also looked at protecting the plan against the unexpected. We discussed a decreasing life insurance policy aligned to the mortgage, so the balance would be cleared if either of them died during the term, and income protection to keep the plan on course if illness stopped them working. (The Financial Conduct Authority does not regulate tax planning, estate planning or will writing.
Why the plan needs regular review
A ten to fifteen year plan is not something you set once and leave. We build in regular reviews because so much can change over that time:
- A change in personal circumstances
- A change in financial circumstances
- A mortgage deal ending, where a mortgage broker may be able to help
- Changes in inflation or interest rates
- Changes in legislation
- New products coming to market
Could you be mortgage free in retirement?
Being mortgage free by retirement is rarely a pipedream. More often it is a question of planning early, comparing the real cost of your mortgage against your other options, and protecting the plan along the way. Whether overpaying, investing, or a blend of both is right for you depends entirely on your rate, your goals and your wider finances.
